American Systems•3 MIN READ
The AMA Filed a Court Brief Yesterday Asking a Judge to Block the New Medicaid Rule Before Millions Get Notified in August.

The AMA Filed a Court Brief Yesterday Asking a Judge to Block the New Medicaid Rule Before Millions Get Notified in August.

E

Erin Calloway

Updated Jul 30, 2026

The American Medical Association filed a court brief on July 28 urging a federal judge to grant a preliminary injunction blocking the new Medicaid “medically frail” rule before August 31. The brief told the court that without a pause, millions of Medicaid beneficiaries with chronic illnesses will spend August scrambling to prove their conditions meet a standard the AMA and 26 states argue was never authorized by Congress.

The case is Commonwealth of Massachusetts et al. v. Oz et al., filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. The rule at issue - CMS’s Interim Final Rule implementing Medicaid work requirements - became final on July 31. States must notify enrollees about changes to the medically frail exemption by August 31.

What the AMA’s Brief Argued

The AMA told the court that the CMS rule’s “significant impairment” test creates a burden for people with cancer, diabetes, heart disease, and other serious conditions that the original statute did not require. “If the judge doesn’t pause parts of CMS’ interim final rule,” the AMA stated, “millions of Medicaid beneficiaries will be running to their providers in August to help them understand CMS’ impermissibly narrow exclusion.”

The AMA entered as an amicus - a friend of the court - supporting the coalition of 26 states and the District of Columbia that filed the underlying lawsuit in late June. The plaintiff states argued that CMS changed the rules mid-implementation, after states had already spent months and money building systems based on different guidance. California’s attorney general noted that Medi-Cal had “relied extensively” on preliminary CMS guidance before the June 3 rule reversed course.

The August 31 Deadline the Court Must Beat

States face two sequential deadlines: August 31 to notify enrollees of changes to the medically frail exemption, and January 1, 2027 for the full work requirements to take effect. The preliminary injunction request asks the court to block the contested portions of the rule before the August 31 notifications go out. If the injunction is not granted in time, states will send notices under a definition of medical frailty that the court may ultimately strike down - creating a second disruption when any ruling arrives.

The Urban Institute projected that work requirements could cause 3 to 7 million Medicaid expansion enrollees to lose coverage. The CMS itself projected the requirements would reduce Medicaid enrollment by approximately 2.3 million individuals in FY 2027.

The Ruling the Court Must Make

The court will weigh the states’ and AMA’s likelihood of success on the merits, the irreparable harm argument, and the public interest. The August 31 deadline constrains the timeline. No ruling date has been publicly announced. The injunction motion, if granted, would pause the contested rule provisions while the case proceeds. If denied, the rule and its notification requirements go forward as written.

References: AMA To Court: Promptly Grant States’ Injunction Request In Medicaid Work Req Lawsuit | AG Campbell Sues Trump Administration Over Unlawful Medicaid Work Requirements Rule | Medicaid Work Reporting Requirements: States Ask a Federal Court to Protect Medically Frail Individuals

AI Assisted Content

AI-Assisted Content

The News And Beyond team was assisted by generative AI technology in creating this content.

Trending

Meghan Steps Back From Brussels Speech as Harry Takes Stage

Caption: Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, at the South by Southwest conference in Austin, Texas, on...

Susan Blake

Meghan Steps Back From Brussels Speech as Harry Takes Stage

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Share Wedding Photo

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig have shared the first public photograph from their wedding, following...

Susan Blake

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' Exes Share Wedding Photo

Kim Kardashian's $148 Holiday Calendar Backfires as Skims Offers Refunds

Caption: Kim Kardashian attends a red carpet event in Sydney, Australia, on September 19, 2012....

Susan Blake

Kim Kardashian's $148 Holiday Calendar Backfires as Skims Offers Refunds

Dolly Parton Estate Ends Nephew Lawsuit but Door Remains Open

Caption: Dolly Parton in a 1977 RCA Records publicity portrait. Credit: David Gahr / Public...

Emily Carter

Dolly Parton Estate Ends Nephew Lawsuit but Door Remains Open

More Holiday Shoppers Will Use AI to Hunt for Deals

More holiday shoppers plan to use AI to find gifts and compare prices, but most...

Alex Mercer

More Holiday Shoppers Will Use AI to Hunt for Deals

Senate Advances Energy Bill as Power-Cost Fight Intensifies

A 73-25 Senate vote has opened debate on an energy bill aimed at speeding construction...

Erin Calloway

Senate Advances Energy Bill as Power-Cost Fight Intensifies

Usher Seeks $700,000 He Says a Business Owes Him

Caption: Usher at the Cannes Film Festival, May 2016. Credit: Georges Biard / CC BY-SA...

Emily Carter

Usher Seeks $700,000 He Says a Business Owes Him

Baron Davis Fights Sister Over a House He Says He Owns

Caption: Former NBA player Baron Davis shooting a free throw, January 2010. Credit: MavsFan28 /...

Susan Blake

Baron Davis Fights Sister Over a House He Says He Owns

Golden Trump Statue on National Mall Targets His Draft Deferment

A gold-colored statue of Donald Trump rubbing his bare foot has appeared on the National...

Thomas Hale

Golden Trump Statue on National Mall Targets His Draft Deferment

Inflation Tops Forecast as Groceries and Housing Squeeze Budgets

Groceries and housing pushed October prices up more than economists expected, adding pressure to everyday...

Daniel Reeves

Inflation Tops Forecast as Groceries and Housing Squeeze Budgets